This is the longest review ever. I do promise there is a (self-sponsored) giveaway at the end though!
You Bar was kind enough to send me some sample premade bars, mixes and shake mixes to review!
You Bar is a neat company – you get to choose and create your own protein bar! What goes in, how big it is, even the protein bar name. They make it fresh and ship it to you. You can also make your own shake and trail mix!
I was initially interested in the trail mix, when Jen recommended You Bar to me after I wrote about making my own trail mix in the beginning of February.
I think it’s pretty cool that they have so many options on what to put in your trail mix on their site, and you can even say you want more or less of a certain type of item (less nuts, normal nuts, more nuts, etc.). They have a lot of options for the bars and shakes too (and even call out what is “most popular” and “recommended”). But I think I would feel more comfortable making a trail mix – if it goes wrong I can always pick out the things I don’t like, ha ha.
Anyway, I digress. Let’s get on with the review.
Only one of the bars sent to me was almost vegan (the Cookie Dough bar which actually had honey in it so it’s not technically vegan), and there were things I could pick out of the mixes to try, but all of the bars and shakes had dairy products in them. So, I recruited some people to help me review the products!!! Thank you, reviewers!
And please, readers, keep in mind that there are a variety of opinions since there were a variety of reviewers!
Honey Cashew Bar – reviewed by Julie (my mom)
Ingredients: Cashew Butter, Honey, Whey Protein, Crunchy Rice Cereal.
Pros: Easy to open, smells good and tastes good. High source of protein (10g per bar).
Cons: Crumbly, lots of calories for a “snack” (220 per bar) and for not being delicious, sticks in your teeth.
Chocolate Trails Trail Mix – reviewed by Julie (and some bits by me)
Ingredients: Pecans, Dried Cherries, Peanuts, Milk Chocolate Raisins, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips, Mini Pretzels.
Pros: Easy to open, everything had great flavor, especially the chocolate chips (which were vegan).
Cons: The pretzels were a bit stale, but still had great flavor.
Mix Up Your Day Trail Mix – reviewed by Julie (and some bits by me)
Ingredients: Oat Bran Sesame Sticks, Organic Cashews, Almonds, Dried Pineapple, Goji Berries, Shredded Coconut.
Pros: Easy to open, the nuts were good quality, everything was tasty.
Cons: Some things were a bit stale and not crisp – maybe from the moisture of the mix?
Wondering: About the dried pineapple vs. chunks. Maybe chunks would have been better!
Training 33 Bar – reviewed by Erin
Ingredients: Whey Protein Isolate, Organic Dates, Almond Butter, Walnuts, Organic Black Mission Figs, Organic Clover Honey, Organic Goji Berries, Organic Cacao Nibs, Organic Flaxseed, All One Vitamin Infusion, Oat Bran, Cinnamon
I feel bad for giving this one to Erin. It did not turn out to be so good and she said she only finished it because she was so hungry and that was all she brought to work! I just copied and pasted what she sent to me because I thought her passionate review was very honest.
The ingredients sounded amazing. Dates? Almond Butter? Figs? Honey? YUM! Don’t really know what Goji berries are but, hey, berries are berries, right? Well, when I opened the bar I noticed right away that it didn’t look that appetizing. There was kind of this gray/white film and the ingredients didn’t seem evenly disbursed.
I like to break off pieces of bars and eat them bits at a time. When I did that with this bar it was kind of crumbly yet it stuck to my fingers and felt kind of slimy/oily.
And the taste? It tasted like chemicals! I’m not sure what it was but it tasted kind of fermented. Not quite bitter but definitely not sweet. And it kept getting stuck in my teeth. I was trying to eat it in a meeting and I’m pretty sure I was unconsciously digging bits of bar out of my molars with my fingernail.
It left a pretty nasty aftertaste in my mouth, too. I’m not sure if it was one of the ingredients that I didn’t like or if it was the combination of one or more things. Overall, NOT a fan even though the ingredient list showed promise.
Vanilla Dream Shake Mix – reviewed by Erin
Ingredients: Soy Protein, Organic Cane Juice, Organic Vanilla Powder.
Pros: Okay flavor – not too sweet and not too bland.
Cons: A bit gritty – may taste better in a smoothie mixed with other flavors to offset it.
Recommendation: Would probably be great with Soymilk.
The Breakfast Shake Shake Mix – reviewed by Erin
Ingredients: Whey Protein, Egg White Powder, Organic Cane Juice, Cocoa Powder, Organic Bananas.
From Erin:
After drinking the Vanilla Dream shake “pure” I decided to add a few things to the Breakfast Shake. I made it into a smoothie with one frozen banana, one cup of baby spinach leaves, and about half a cup of cow milk. It dissolved much better in the shake and mostly just became a protein powder additive with a hint of chocolate flavor. The chocolate flavor wasn’t very strong, though. And even though it claimed to have banana in it I didn’t notice any “extra” banana taste on top of the banana I added.
I liked that it had additional egg protein in it and it didn’t taste any different from my regular protein powder. That’s a plus! Also, the calorie content was decent for the amount of powder and the ingredient list was all things I recognized. However, I’d rather just buy a can of protein powder and get more for my money since I didn’t think this tasted all that different. But, if you’re really into no extraneous ingredients then maybe this shake mix is for you.
Great Date with Chocolate Bar – reviewed by Steven
Ingredients: Organic Dates, Whey Protein Isolate, Organic Honey, Cocoa.
Pros: Decent flavor.
Cons: Like eating a bar of clay. A bit too dense and chewy.
Cookie Dough Bar – reviewed by ME!
Ingredients: Organic Dates, Cashew Butter, Cashews, Clover Honey, Semisweet Chocola Chips, Vanilla Extract.
Pros: Actually tastes like cookie dough! Well, a healthy version of it.
Cons: A bit crumbly.
Thank you You Bar, for sending me these items to review!!! (I still have one bar left, but I wanted to get this review out!)
Since I was originally interested in You Bar for their custom mix, I would like to sponsor a custom mix giveaway!
You Bar Trail Mix Giveaway Rules
- One reader will receive one custom trail mix (13 packages per box) from You Bar.
- Required to enter the giveaway: go to the site and tell me what you are going to put in your mix!
- This giveaway is open until 5:00 PM CST on Friday April 6. I will use random.org to select the winner. I will announce the winner on Saturday April 7.
- This giveaway is open to readers in the US.